When it comes to logistics and supply chain management, the ability to accurately track containers and assets is not just a convenience—it’s a necessity. As global trade continues to expand, businesses face increasing pressure to ensure that goods are transported efficiently and securely from one point to another. This is where advanced tracking technologies come into play, providing the critical data needed to monitor cargo across vast distances and through complex transportation networks.
This article aims to explore and elucidate the functionalities and strategic advantages of two cutting-edge Internet of Things (IoT) technologies utilized in container tracking: LoRaWAN and NB-IoT. Each of these technologies offers unique benefits tailored to different aspects of container logistics and there is a device that offers both. By comparing and contrasting these technologies, this piece seeks to provide insights into how they can optimize tracking operations, enhance asset visibility, and improve overall supply chain resilience. Whether you’re involved in maritime shipping, overland freight, or intermodal transport, understanding these technologies will help you make informed decisions about which tracking solutions are best suited for your specific logistics needs.
LoRaWAN (Long Range Wide Area Network) stands as a pivotal technology in the realm of IoT, especially suited for tracking applications that demand long-range capabilities and low power consumption. It operates on a protocol designed to connect low-bandwidth, battery-powered devices across large distances, with a range that can extend up to 15 kilometers in rural settings and around 5 kilometers in urban environments. This makes it particularly effective for tracking containers as they move through less accessible areas or across expansive distances without the need for frequent battery replacements. LoRaWAN’s robust signal penetration is also ideal for ensuring connectivity in challenging environments, such as inside metal shipping containers or at remote ports, where traditional cellular signals might falter. The technology’s ability to provide real-time location updates, despite these hurdles, ensures that logistics operators can maintain a continuous line of sight to their assets, enhancing security and operational efficiency.
Narrowband IoT (NB-IoT) leverages the existing cellular network infrastructure to offer wide-area connectivity tailored for applications that require continuous connectivity and greater power efficiency. Unlike LoRaWAN, NB-IoT utilizes licensed spectrum which provides it with a stable and secure connection, making it highly reliable for tracking containers in densely populated urban areas where cellular coverage is extensive. NB-IoT’s main advantage in tracking applications lies in its deep penetration capabilities, ensuring reliable indoor and underground coverage—ideal for urban logistics environments like warehouses and distribution centers. Furthermore, because it operates in the licensed spectrum, NB-IoT supports a massive number of devices over a single network, facilitating the tracking of numerous containers simultaneously without the risk of interference. Its power efficiency does not just extend battery life but also reduces the operational costs associated with maintaining large fleets of tracking devices, thereby optimizing logistics operations across global supply chains.
Together, these technologies equip logistics and supply chain managers with powerful tools to maintain an uninterrupted connection to their containers, regardless of location, ensuring that every link in the supply chain is visible and secure.
Both the LoRaWAN and NB-IoT variants of the container tracker share several key features that enhance their utility across various tracking applications:
The LoRaWAN variant stands out due to its suitability for areas with limited cellular coverage and its long-range communication abilities:
The NB-IoT variant leverages the widespread availability and stability of cellular networks, making it preferable for use in well-connected urban and industrial areas:
The LoRaWAN device excels in remote or rural areas where cellular coverage is sparse or non-existent. Its ability to transmit data over long distances without the need for cellular infrastructure makes it indispensable for tracking containers through desolate regions such as open seas, rural farmlands, or mountainous areas. The extended battery life ensures continuous operation without frequent maintenance, which is crucial for shipments that undergo long transit periods through areas lacking technical support.
In contrast, the NB-IoT device is optimized for environments where cellular network coverage is robust and reliable. This makes it particularly effective for tracking containers in high-traffic urban areas and busy ports where cellular connectivity is consistent. The NB-IoT’s use of established cellular networks allows for real-time tracking data, essential for managing the fast-paced movement of goods in metropolitan logistics hubs, ensuring timely updates and accurate location data.
The comparative analysis between LoRaWAN and NB-IoT technologies in container tracking devices is summarized in the following table, focusing on connectivity and coverage, as well as cost-effectiveness and scalability:
Connectivity and Coverage
Excels in remote or rural areas without stable cellular service, using long-range communication to maintain connectivity. Capable of switching seamlessly between indoor and outdoor environments, but may experience signal loss in highly urbanized or infrastructurally dense areas. Power consumption is optimized for long battery life, suitable for areas and applications where maintenance and battery replacement are challenging.
Performs best in areas with established cellular network coverage, ensuring continuous connectivity in urban and dense environments. Handles transitions between indoor and outdoor environments smoothly due to its reliance on cellular networks. Generally has higher power consumption, which may require more frequent battery changes or recharging, particularly suitable for areas where maintenance access is more feasible.
Cost-Effectiveness and Scalability
Installation and maintenance costs are lower due to less reliance on cellular infrastructure. LoRaWAN networks can be scaled with relatively low incremental costs, making it cost-effective for expanding operations in remote areas.
Higher initial costs due to the need for SIM cards and cellular service fees. However, the reliance on existing cellular networks can reduce the need for building additional infrastructure. Scalable across regions with a strong cellular presence, potentially offering lower operational costs per unit as the network expands.
This comparative analysis has highlighted the distinct capabilities and best use cases for each tracking device. The LoRaWAN device is particularly suited for remote areas where cellular coverage is limited, offering long-range communication and extended battery life, making it ideal for international shipping routes or rural supply chains. On the other hand, the NB-IoT device excels in urban environments with stable cellular networks, providing continuous connectivity and additional safety features, ideal for tracking high-value assets in densely populated areas.
Choosing the right tracking technology depends on specific logistics needs such as the type of containers, the geographical routes they traverse, and the value of the tracked assets. For operations that span remote areas, the LoRaWAN device is recommended due to its robust range and durability. Conversely, for urban-centric operations where containers or assets require constant monitoring and quick response capabilities, the NB-IoT device is preferable. Companies should also consider the frequency of access to sites for maintenance when choosing between devices with different battery life expectations.
Looking forward, IoT tracking technologies are poised for significant advancements with the integration of AI and machine learning, which could further enhance predictive analytics and real-time decision-making. These improvements are expected to increase the efficiency and security of supply chains, reducing costs, and improving service delivery. Additionally, as global connectivity standards evolve, there may be an increase in hybrid devices that combine the best features of LoRaWAN and NB-IoT technologies, offering unparalleled flexibility and coverage. This evolution will undoubtedly continue to transform the logistics sector, driving innovations that make tracking more accurate, reliable, and cost-effective.
The landscape of IoT tracking technologies is rapidly evolving, and staying abreast of these changes is crucial for logistics and supply chain managers aiming to leverage the latest innovations to bolster their operations and competitive advantage.
Lansitec Container Tracker Bringing LoRaWAN and NB-IoT in Modern Logistics When it comes to logistics and supply chain management, the ability to accurately track containers and assets is not just
NB-IoT Container Tracker Lansitec NB-IoT and LTE-M GNSS container tracker supports indoor and outdoor tracking, asset management with worldwide network coverage. It has 5-year battery life (30 minutes report interval)
The Lansitec Container Tracker is a device designed to track the location of sea containers, factory containers, and assets during transport. It utilizes a combination of GNSS, BLE, LoRaWAN® technology,
LoRaWAN Container Tracker Lansitec Container Tracker is designed based on GNSS, Bluetooth and LoRaWAN technology for indoor and outdoor tracking. It has an ultra-long standby time and IP68 enclosure that
Accurate outdoor and indoor tracking: The versatile tracker comes embedded with Bluetooth for indoor tracking and GNSS (GPS, Beidou, Glonass) for outdoor tracking. The UUID of the device can be
Lansitec Industrial Tracker is powered by GPS, Bluetooth, and LoRaWan technologies to help you achieve precise asset tracking across industries. The tracker can send over 180,000 Bluetooth tracking messages over
Reach out to us if you’re looking for a cost-effective tracking solution, a partner within your region or simply want to learn more about our technology.
contact@lansitec.com
